Judy L. Mandel
Archive for the ‘Replacement children’ Category
Psychological Look at Replacement Children
Saturday, August 14th, 2010Another interesting look at replacement children at http://tinyurl.com/yjqkfay
What is a Replacement Child?
Saturday, August 7th, 2010When I start to talk about my book, Replacement Child, the first question I am usually asked is “what is a replacement child?” I then explain that it is not a term I invented, but that I found the term in my research around grieving and loss, especially that of a child. The following link gives a very clear definition, and offers clinical background to the reasons and cautions behind the syndrome:
“The replacement child–a developmental tragedy”
Friday, July 30th, 2010Van Gogh’s Fantasies of Replacement: Being a Double and a Twin — Blum 57 6: 1311 — Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association
Thursday, July 29th, 2010JOHN TRAVOLTA and KELLY PRESTON’S HAPPY NEWS – a REPLACEMENT CHILD?
Monday, July 26th, 2010Reading the news that John Travolta and Kelly Preston are expecting a baby a little over a year after the death of their 16-year old son Jett made me think of my own parents’ decision to have another child after losing their eldest daughter. I am that ‘replacement child’ and though many people don’t like the term–it doesn’t have to be a bad thing.
John Travolta and Kelly Preston can prepare to welcome this new child into their family as a unique individual and cherished addition to their family. With awareness of some of the possible pitfalls, Travolta and Preston can mitigate possible negative effects of being a replacement child as their child grows up. Although there may be no ‘getting over’ the devastating loss of a child, a new baby may help Travolta and Preston emerge from their grief and can be a source of healing.
I know there have been several blog comments in the last couple of days about the news, and about Kelly Preston being 47 years old–but that is really none of anyone’s business but Travolta and Preston’s! I’m sure there are plenty of over 40 women right now saying “better you than me” thinking of childbirth and caring for a newborn. I say if Kelly Preston is up for it, we should applaud her!
I wish them all the best, and my hope is that this new child never feels like a replacement child at all. That is totally within the power of Travolta and Preston’s attitude and understanding.
Happy Birthday Sis
Monday, June 14th, 2010I’ve been trying to think of anything but this to write about on my blog, but with my sister Linda’s birthday coming tomorrow, my mind and heart are full of her. She would have been 61 this June 15th, 2010 and I would never have imagined her not making it to this day. If you’ve read any of my work, and especially Replacement Child, you know what a special woman she was. But, I can’t help feeling that whatever I’ve written about her, I haven’t done justice to her bravery, her humor, her loving spirit.
She was always my big sister–looking out for me in her own way. Worried how I would take things, react to things, understand her. To her, I was always the fragile one who internalized everything a bit too much for everyone’s liking. She screened her illnesses and chronic pain from me, I know, so that I only probably saw the tip of the iceberg of her fight. Protecting me as always, even as I was under the illusion that I protected her.
Linda was the constant in my life, the touchstone for family memories, the one I would call when I wanted to confirm “did this really happen?” The only one who could say for sure. We were far apart in miles, but always close. Hers was the first phone call I would make with good family news–or when something went wrong. We relied on each other for our honest viewpoint that only had each others’ best interest at heart. No agendas, no manipulation, just love.
We made each other laugh. Every phone call we ever had included at least one good belly laugh. Lately we would laugh together at some shared idea of what our parents would have done or said in a certain situation. She would only have to say my father’s name with a certain inflection–”A-L-B-E-R-T….” the way my mother would have said it in exasperation–and she would set me off. Or I’d remind her about the time she brought me to pick out a parakeet at a store and I pointed at it and it spiraled off the perch to it’s death. That one never ceased to produce hysterics in us both.
My sister was destined, for whatever reason, to have a hard life. Starting with a plane crash that burned and injured her at two, the ramifications followed her all of her life. But, she didn’t see it that way. And, she would have bristled at being called disabled or special needs or challenged. In truth, her injuries and scars gave her a unique understanding of the human spirit. She saw beneath the surface of many people to the good that is often be overlooked. I know she had an understanding that I never will. One of my regrets is that I never let her teach me more about her vision of the world. Another is that we didn’t spend more time together.
Here’s what I do know. Linda–and my parents too–would want me to celebrate life, not dwell on death. So on your birthday, sis, I will celebrate the life you had and that I was lucky enough to share. And, the love I could always feel from you.
All content © Judy L. Mandel 2008 - 2010



